Bellarmine College Preparatory’s football turnaround has been thrown into uncertainty after the Central Coast Section (CCS) ruled that the San Jose school used an ineligible transfer student-athlete during the 2026 season. The decision requires the Bells to forfeit all six of their victories, changing their record from 6–3 to 0–9 and removing them from the Central Coast Section playoff picture.
The ruling became public on November 3 and was reported in detail on November 4, turning what had been one of the Bay Area’s most encouraging high school football stories into a major eligibility dispute. Bellarmine had secured three nonleague victories and three West Catholic Athletic League (WCAL) wins under first-year head coach Tom Williams. Those results will now be recorded as defeats under the section’s eligibility ruling.
Bellarmine Principal Rod Jemison acknowledged that the school violated CIF and CCS transfer eligibility rules but criticized the consequences imposed on the entire team. The administration has indicated that it intends to pursue legal avenues to challenge the decision, even as the coaching staff prepares the players for their scheduled game against Archbishop Riordan.
CCS Eligibility Ruling Changes Bellarmine’s 2026 Football Record
The Central Coast Section determined that Bellarmine used a transfer student-athlete who was not eligible to compete. According to the explanation provided by Jemison, the CCS outlined two consequences: the student-athlete would be declared ineligible, and Bellarmine would have to forfeit the games in which the player participated.

The ruling changes the team’s official overall record from 6–3 to 0–9. Its WCAL record also moves from 3–3 to 0–6, eliminating the wins that had helped the Bells become competitive in one of Northern California’s most demanding high school football leagues.
The decision does not change the scores that were played on the field. Instead, it changes the official results because of the eligibility violation. That distinction is central to the dispute: Bellarmine is not challenging the fact that the games took place, but the severity and reach of the penalties.
In a letter to parents obtained by the San Francisco Chronicle, Jemison stated that the school did not dispute that a violation occurred. However, he said the administration disagreed with the consequences and their effect on the entire football team.
Jemison also accepted that Bellarmine had responsibility for understanding and following the governing rules. He indicated that the school would examine gaps in its oversight and address the procedures that allowed the violation to happen.
The CCS has not publicly identified the student-athlete in the reporting available about the ruling. The central issue is the school’s responsibility to confirm transfer eligibility before allowing a student to participate in varsity competition.
Six Victories Erased From a Season That Showed Major Improvement
The forfeitures carry additional weight because Bellarmine had made significant progress after several difficult seasons. The program entered 2026 looking for a reset after going a combined 4–26 over the previous three seasons.
The Bells had also struggled in WCAL competition, going without a league victory during the previous two campaigns. Williams arrived as the new head coach with experience at St. Francis, Stanford and Yale, and the team began producing results that suggested a different direction for the program.
Bellarmine’s six victories came against a combination of nonleague and WCAL opponents.
| Opponent | Original Result | Competition |
|---|---|---|
| Ann Sobrato | 37–6 win | Nonleague |
| Campolindo | 17–16 win | Nonleague |
| Palo Alto | 38–18 win | Nonleague |
| Archbishop Mitty | 10–7 win | WCAL |
| Valley Christian | 7–0 win | WCAL |
| Sacred Heart Cathedral | 24–20 win | WCAL |
The nonleague results gave Bellarmine early momentum. A 37–6 victory over Ann Sobrato on August 29 was followed by a narrow 17–16 win against Campolindo and a 38–18 result against Palo Alto.
The team then carried that confidence into league play. A 10–7 victory over Archbishop Mitty and a 7–0 shutout against Valley Christian demonstrated that Bellarmine could compete in close, defensive games against WCAL opponents.
Its most recent victory came on October 30, when the Bells defeated Sacred Heart Cathedral 24–20. That result had helped place the team at 6–3 overall and 3–3 in league play before the eligibility decision changed the standings.
All six victories are now subject to forfeiture. The team’s three losses remain losses, producing the revised 0–9 record.
Tom Williams’ First Season Takes an Unexpected Turn
The eligibility ruling interrupts a promising first season for Tom Williams, who took over Bellarmine’s football program in 2026.

Williams brought a varied coaching background to San Jose. Before joining Bellarmine, he had worked as an assistant at St. Francis and Stanford and served as head coach at Yale University. His arrival gave the Bells a new coaching direction after a period in which the program had struggled to produce consistent results.
The early results suggested that the change was having an effect. Bellarmine won all three of its nonleague games and secured three victories in the WCAL, a meaningful improvement for a team that had not won a league game in either of the previous two seasons.
The forfeitures, however, create a difficult situation for the players and coaching staff. The team’s on-field progress remains part of its season, but the official record no longer reflects those performances.
Jemison’s statement made clear that the school intends to support the team through the remainder of its schedule. The principal said the football team and coaching staff were preparing for the next game with the full support of the administration.
That message matters because the ruling arrived during the final stretch of the regular season, when players would ordinarily be preparing for postseason competition. Instead, Bellarmine must deal with the consequences of the eligibility decision while attempting to finish its schedule.
Bellarmine Loses Its Place in the CCS Playoff Picture
Before the forfeitures, Bellarmine had positioned itself for a return to the Central Coast Section playoffs. The program had not reached the section postseason since 2022, making the 2026 turnaround particularly significant.
According to the San Francisco Chronicle, Bellarmine had been seeded sixth in the Division 1 playoff picture heading into the week. The six victories had given the team a realistic path back to postseason football after several years outside the playoff field.
The revised 0–9 record changes that outlook entirely. With the victories removed, Bellarmine no longer has the results required to remain in the same playoff position.
The impact also extends beyond the school. High school playoff brackets are built around official records, league results and qualifying criteria. When a team loses several victories through forfeiture, the change can affect the positioning of other programs competing for postseason opportunities.
Sacred Heart Cathedral, Valley Christian, Archbishop Mitty and Palo Alto were identified as schools that could benefit from the revised results and receive more favorable playoff seeds.
The exact effect depends on the final CCS standings and official bracket decisions. However, the Bellarmine ruling has clearly introduced a major change to the Division 1 playoff picture.
For programs that were competing close to the qualification line, the forfeitures could influence which teams advance and where they are placed.
Why Transfer Eligibility Rules Matter in California High School Sports
Transfer eligibility is an important part of California high school athletics. Students who move from one school to another do not automatically receive unrestricted varsity eligibility in every situation.
The California Interscholastic Federation establishes statewide rules, while the Central Coast Section administers eligibility requirements for schools in its territory. Transfer cases can involve documentation, residency circumstances, hardship considerations and sit-out periods.
Bellarmine’s own student-athlete handbook explains that transfer students may need to complete eligibility procedures before competing at the varsity level. It also identifies the CCS as the authority responsible for granting certain forms of transfer eligibility.
The purpose of these requirements is to maintain fair competition between schools and establish consistent standards for student-athletes who change schools. They also place responsibility on athletic departments to verify eligibility before players participate in official contests.
The Bellarmine case illustrates how a violation can affect more than the individual student involved. When an ineligible athlete participates in games, the resulting penalties can extend to the team’s official record and postseason status.
For Bellarmine, the administration has acknowledged that the school was responsible for compliance. Jemison’s comments indicate that the school intends to review its oversight procedures, although the public reporting has not detailed the specific circumstances behind the transfer or the administrative steps that led to the violation.
The situation also highlights why schools must complete eligibility checks before allowing transfer students to take part in varsity games. A failure to resolve those questions can create consequences that extend through an entire season.
Bellarmine Plans to Challenge the Penalty While Preparing for Riordan
Although Bellarmine cannot appeal the decision through the CCS process, the school has indicated that it will explore legal options in an effort to overturn the forfeitures.
That approach creates two parallel priorities for the administration. The first is determining whether there is a legal path to challenge the penalty. The second is supporting the players and coaches as they complete the football schedule.
The Bells are scheduled to face Archbishop Riordan on Saturday, November 7. The game was originally part of a season in which Bellarmine was building momentum and pursuing a playoff return. It now comes after a ruling that has officially erased the team’s victories.
The school has not indicated that it intends to abandon the remaining schedule. Jemison’s letter stated that the football program was preparing for the Riordan matchup with administrative support.
The next few days will therefore be important for Bellarmine. The legal response could determine whether the school has another avenue to contest the forfeitures, while the team’s preparation will test its ability to remain focused after a major setback.
The CCS decision also leaves questions about the final playoff bracket and whether any additional administrative developments could change the official standings before postseason competition begins.
A Difficult Ending to Bellarmine’s Football Turnaround
Bellarmine’s 2026 season had been a significant step forward for a program seeking to regain its place among the Bay Area’s competitive high school football teams. Three nonleague wins and three WCAL victories represented tangible progress after a combined 4–26 record over the previous three seasons.
The eligibility ruling has changed the official outcome of that work. Instead of entering the final week with a 6–3 record and a potential playoff position, the Bells now carry an 0–9 mark and face the loss of their postseason opportunity.
The school has accepted responsibility for the violation while arguing that the consequences extend too far. Its decision to consider legal options means the dispute may continue beyond the initial CCS ruling.
For the players, coaches and families involved, the immediate challenge is finishing the season while the administration addresses the eligibility matter. For the wider San Jose and Bay Area high school football community, the case is a reminder that transfer compliance can have consequences that reach far beyond one student-athlete.
Bellarmine’s results on the field remain part of the story, but the official record will now be defined by the CCS decision unless the school succeeds in changing the outcome through another legal avenue.


